final fantasy xiii mafia [n3]

By Peterofl. 12/05/11, 03:26 pm

Quote :: I kind agree with Alex, I'm a bit worried that you claimed Lightning on the first day, not a good idea for the cop to out themselves so quickly in my opinion.

Or I could just be lynched. Which you were going to do (and fair enough).

Well, I guess from this I've learnt to be incredibly boring on day 1 and not promote any discussion because seriously with you guys if nothing extremely controversial is posted you're all just like "I'm not suspicious of anyone" and then don't post for a few days.

By RainbowMoonDust. 12/05/11, 03:27 pm

Quote :: RainbowMoonDust wrote:
Quote:
/Facepalm
Idk. If scum ninja-lynched it would mean one dead scum. Wahey.

@Zeo: Are you saying you don't believe Peter's claim then?

Double Facepalm
No. Until otherwise proven, hes the cop, and I don't really want him lynched. What I meant was:

In a regular game, cop finds scum at night. Reveals result during day. Scum gets lynched. Cop gets killed in night.
If scum ninja-lynched peter, cop would be dead, but the scum lynched d2. 1 dead cop for 1 mafia - same result. It's not ideal, but the result is similar.

Oh I see, I totally misread your statement before, total durp moment on my part, lol. sweatdrop

By Phlaming Phoenix-. 12/05/11, 03:33 pm

Imo peyer, play to your role.
If your the cop, sit down and shut up for a bit. Promoting discussion is one thing, saying 'OH LOOK AT ME EVERYONE I DEFINITELY KNOW STUFF THAT YOU GUYS DONT!'
Subtlety is an art, and is incredibly important in this game when you are a power role. I don't mean to sound condescending or nasty here man, but seriously you need to learn when to stop talking.
If you are mafia: Bad move, you are going to die, if not today than probably tonight.
If you are actually the cop: Bad move, you have painted a fantastically huge bullseye on your head, and if even the dumbest mafia will be have to be really really un observant, or heinously drunk to miss it. Both would also work.

Besides from Peyer, I still am quite suspicious of Madja. I know, there is nothing she can really say to defend herself, but the damage has been done, and the damage is enough for me.
For day one at least.

By Li-Bai. 12/05/11, 03:34 pm

damage what damage

By P-Layton. 12/05/11, 03:36 pm

So... right.
I don't think Peter's mafia. Especially with his claim. But that's just me. I'm not suspicious of him in the least, actually, I don't know why.

Vote XOrengenOX

By Selphiroth. 12/05/11, 03:47 pm

Peterofl wrote:: Town 8/12:

1. Lightning - Cop/Vig
...

I'm completely theme-illiterate, but I want to contribute, so I did my best. Feel free to fix it because I've probably got tons of stuff wrong and if Orphan and Barth are definitely evil I don't know where to put Cid or Yaag etc.

Peterofl wrote:: I'm the main protagonist in the game according to wikipedia. (OMG, I'm the only illiterate who actually researched the game!) so I without a counter I don't see why there isn't a reason not to believe me in a game this small.

So I jumped on Wiki myself. How did you get the vig, then, Peter? Nothing on Wiki indicated that.

By RainbowMoonDust. 12/05/11, 03:51 pm

Hmmm I just realized something. I remember Li-Bai posting this a while back:

Quote :: Still though, nothing to defend myself from,so.

Also my first (proper) post I would have another look at

So I took a look and this is what I found:

Quote :: Hello I am making a post

I wouldn't rule out a few other characters as well for townside. Like if there's Snow, what about his lackeys Team? Gadot, Lebreau, Maqui? If I remember Maqui's role in the game right, it could make sense to have him as a cop or investigative role of some sort? idk

/themewank

Now I didn't say anything at the time because I thought that she hinting that she was the Cop, I mean why else would she refer us to that particular post? (It was the first one I found after her introduction post that everyone does at the start of a game). I kept my mouth shut in the hopes that Scum wouldn't spot it.

But then Peter went and claimed Cop.

Li-Bai: So what do you say to this? Why did you tell people to have another look at this post?

By Phlaming Phoenix-. 12/05/11, 04:04 pm

Li-Bai wrote:: damage what damage

That damage sad

You make a post if and only if your name is called. Minus your very first post or so.
You claim to have nothing to say, but surely you have an opinion on a day one claim of cop, not to mention all the people discussing it and sticking their heads out. When you are mafia you tend to try and stay under the radar by saying as little as possible. Just from experience and seeing you play, nothing personal :)

By Li-Bai. 12/05/11, 04:11 pm

RainbowMoonDust wrote:: Li-Bai: So what do you say to this? Why did you tell people to have another look at this post?

I'm glad someone listened to that

I'm not pointing at the main statement of that post, rather the WHOLE post. Get me yet?

@PP Well if someone addresses me of course I'm gonna talk! D: I don't know, all this crazy seems pretty usual to me but I'm still getting used to it.
and didn't you already say everything re copclaim

ps actually when i'm mafia i thought i tended to talk more buut y'know

By RainbowMoonDust. 12/05/11, 04:14 pm

Quote :: I'm glad someone listened to that

I'm not pointing at the main statement of that post, rather the WHOLE post. Get me yet?

I get you and I see what you were doing there, I did wonder if I was barking up the wrong tree with that post but I had to make sure. nodnod

By Phlaming Phoenix-. 12/05/11, 04:22 pm

@Li-Bai:
It's just how I have seen you play before. Crazy talk is usual, sure. People claiming cop on day one? Not so usual. As for me saying everything, I believe I missed out a fair amount. And it is always helpful to add your own opinion, even if other people have already said it, or if you disagree with people.
That is essentially what I am doing with my vote on you. Stating my opinion. I am not urging people to join me just yet as I am not 100% on this. Tis just what I am seeing, and if no one else sees it that is fine by me for now. :)

By creature124. 12/05/11, 05:23 pm

Okay, well until proven otherwise, Peter is the cop. He may be a moron for putting himself in a situation where he had to claim day one, but he is the cop. Unvote: Peterofl

I am intruiged by Li-bai's hinting, and skeptical. I had also taken it as a cop hint, but she is now saying that isn't the case. And the other option to what she was suggesting strikes me as less likely, given the small number of players in the game.

I'm not placing a vote yet, but something here doesn't add up.

By Li-Bai. 12/05/11, 05:30 pm

What is the other option and why do you think it is less likely?

By Li-Bai. 12/05/11, 05:30 pm

*what is it that you see is the other option

By P-Layton. 13/05/11, 01:34 am

Li-Bai wrote:: *what is it that you see is the other option

I know this isn't directed at me, but hey!
You being any other investigative role. For example. perhaps you're a analyst, that's what they're called, right? The ones that can compare two people's win conditions? I think it is. So yeah - you could be an analyst.
I don't know why creature124 would consider that less likely, but I don't know enough about making an equal game to really comment on that.

By Madam Madhatter. 13/05/11, 05:39 am

Pffft.
Okay, so Peterofl is either fake-claiming or actually cop. Happy to leave him since we will find out for sure one way or another.

Out of the bandwagon against him RainbowMoonDust is the most suspicious to me, she joined the bandwagon against Peterofl just as it started to pick up with little reasoning adding the 'pressing for infomation' after Peter attacked her for the lynch. Also how she removed the vote was interesting.

RainbowMoonDust wrote:: Hmmm, I'll remove my lynch for now, while I think this over.

[Unvote: Peterrofl]

Not sure I really believe you Peter, mainly because I don't know much theme wise but this is better than a ninja lynch by Scum while we process this new information.

By RainbowMoonDust. 13/05/11, 06:36 am

Quote :: Out of the bandwagon against him RainbowMoonDust is the most suspicious to me, she joined the bandwagon against Peterofl just as it started to pick up with little reasoning adding the 'pressing for infomation' after Peter attacked her for the lynch. Also how she removed the vote was interesting.
RainbowMoonDust wrote:
Hmmm, I'll remove my lynch for now, while I think this over.

[Unvote: Peterrofl]

Not sure I really believe you Peter, mainly because I don't know much theme wise but this is better than a ninja lynch by Scum while we process this new information.

I don't think I had little reasoning, I just wanted Peter to explain stuff that's all. I do agree that I was being hasty in removing my lynch but basically because when Peter claimed I went 'Oh crap we have a Cop one vote away from lynch! D8' panicked a little and removed it. The thought that any scum that hammered him would die as a result (As Zeo pointed out) didn't even cross my mind which was only focused on saving our Cop at the time.

By RainbowMoonDust. 13/05/11, 06:40 am

Quote :: I know this isn't directed at me, but hey!
You being any other investigative role. For example. perhaps you're a analyst, that's what they're called, right? The ones that can compare two people's win conditions? I think it is. So yeah - you could be an analyst.
I don't know why creature124 would consider that less likely, but I don't know enough about making an equal game to really comment on that.

I think what Greg was trying to point out is that we wouldn't have the numbers for all the characters that' Li-Bai mentioned.

Quote :: Quote:
Hello I am making a post

I wouldn't rule out a few other characters as well for townside. Like if there's Snow, what about his lackeys Team? Gadot, Lebreau, Maqui? If I remember Maqui's role in the game right, it could make sense to have him as a cop or investigative role of some sort? idk

/themewank

Quote :: I am intruiged by Li-bai's hinting, and skeptical. I had also taken it as a cop hint, but she is now saying that isn't the case. And the other option to what she was suggesting strikes me as less likely, given the small number of players in the game.

That is what I think but I could be wrong.

By Li-Bai. 13/05/11, 07:28 am

Pop quiz! : D

Can we think of a reason why I might mention these characters even if to a theme literate they may be 'less likely'?

By commandercandyfloss. 13/05/11, 08:51 am

Ah, I clicked, I think. I think I get what Libai is hinting at.

By creature124. 13/05/11, 09:28 am

Li bai is not an analyst. The GM has stated that this is a very basic setup, and the analyst is very non-basic. It is incredibly unlikely.

I certainly do think that it is unlikely that any/all of the character li bai mentioned are in the round. I took her post as a hint that she was one of them, that I do find unlikely.

This basically feels to me like she is scum, and establishing her fakeclaim. And I'm getting tired with all the tiptoeing around. Li-bai - either claim, or don't claim. make up your mind. Either way, Vote: Li-bai. This is sus as hell.

By Li-Bai. 13/05/11, 09:49 am

/facepalm

i was under the impression that this game was all about beating around the bush until absolutely necessary

I AM GADOT and a Vanilla. If my character is in then surely at least one other is as well.

By Phlaming Phoenix-. 13/05/11, 10:05 am

>_>

Well that did not go how I intended. Yeah she isn't kidding.

Unvote Li-bai

**Guest** Guest

RainbowMoonDust [1/7] — Peterofl
Peterofl [3/7] — XOrengenOX, Selphiroth, Zeorymer
Li-Bai [1/7] — creature124
XOrengenOX [1/7] — P-Layton

not voting
Admin
Lumissne
RainbowMoonDust
Li-Bai
Madam Madhatter
Phlaming Phoenix-

some good discussion going on everyone

By RainbowMoonDust. 13/05/11, 01:54 pm

So we are at a standstill again it seems. Top suspicion time again? Well I'm going to post some that I have if it helps to get things moving again.

Madam_Madhatter: I've noticed very little activity from her which is unusual as she's normally more active and when she does post it's to say that she finds someone suspicious most of the time. Apart from that she doesn't really seem to contribute much to the discussions which is seems a bit strange to me when there has been so much going on to talk about lately. I can't help but wonder if she is trying to stay under the radar and pin an easy lynch on someone. :think:

As for Rengen I'm still uncertain about her. :think:

That's about all I can think of for now.

**Sponsored content**